Here's a letter I just wrote to J. K. Rowling, letting her know that the collective we I identify myself with in the Harry Potter generation wants more Harry and less Barry. Having written opposite poles with Harry Potter on one side and Casual Vacancy on the other, I wanted to cast my vote with Harry for her future works.
Dear Mrs. Rowling,
I am a proud member
of the Harry Potter generation. I read the books, I watch the movies, I
philosophize over their content and meaning, I buy the merchandise, and I've
visited the theme park. I believed in Harry Potter, and I believed in J. K.
Rowling.
So, when I learned
that a new J. K. Rowling book was coming out, I already had my plans booked.
Obviously, I was going to be the first one in line to get that book, whatever
it was. After seven books, it was obvious what to expect. No, not necessarily
wizards and magic, but top-of-the-line, inspiring storytelling.
Months later, my
wish came true, and I stood at the front of the line. Okay, well, I was the
line, but there I was, way more awake than any of the store associates at the
counter. They had to ring up my copy of The
Casual Vacancy a couple of times because we hadn't actually hit the
release time yet, but then I was happily on my way. Apologizing to my homework,
I knew the book would be done before the end of the day, If I had anything to
do with it.
The first lesson we
learned is that muggles are pitiful. Barry gets one head-splitting headache,
gives up, and dies. How embarrassing. Harry's head split open every other
chapter and you didn't see him putting
up such a big fuss.
Unfortunately,
that's the only lesson we learn. We learn that while stories about wizards are
full of courage, daring, moral strength, sacrifice, friendship, and love,
stories about muggles are filled with vulgarity, immorality, and abuse. Indeed,
I was done with the book before the end of the day, but not because I had
finished reading it.
Surely, I thought,
there are two J. K. Rowling's. There is no way such opposite works could be
penned by the same hand. On one side, one of the greatest masterpieces to grace
a bookshelf in our age, and on the other a handful of pages containing such trash
as I would never touch, much less willingly invite into my library. Not even
the name 'Rowling' could get me to read more profanity, sex, and disrespect for
all Harry taught us to live by. I sadly made my way to the store and returned
what I had expected to be the book of the year.
I thought I believed
in Harry Potter and J. K. Rowling. The Casual
Vacancy corrected me. I still believe in Harry Potter; that has not
changed. It's just that I must now consider it distinct and separate from the
author's name on the cover.
I would very much
like to believe in J. K. Rowling again. If that means waiting for more
"children's books," so be it. We have read quality, legendary
literature from you before; we know it is possible. We are the Harry Potter
generation, and we expect Harry Potter values. If you abandon them, we will not
follow. If you have more stories worth
telling, we ask to hear them and will accept and love them. If you only have
more Casual Vacancy in you, we will be
grateful for what we have received in Harry Potter but mourn that it was the
end of Rowling.
Hoping for the best,
Joseph Simonson